Consensus All-America selections as defined by the NCAA.
In the Yrs column, a "1" indicates a 1st Team selection and a "2" indicates a 2nd Team selection.

Consensus All-Americans

Consensus All-Americans Table
Rk Player Count Yrs
1Tony Lavelli31946-2, 1948-2, 1949-1
2Gilmore Kinney21905-1, 1907-1
3W.P. Arnold11915-1
4Willard Hyatt11905-1
5Orson Kinney11917-1
6Haskell Noyes11908-1
7Charles Taft11917-1