Consensus All-America Teams (1909-10 to 1918-19)

Total number of selections are listed in parentheses for repeat winners.

1918-19 NCAA

1st Team
Tony Hinkle Chicago
Leon Marcus Syracuse
Lance Farwell Navy
George Parrish Virginia Tech
Erling Platou Minnesota
Dutch Lonborg Kansas
Dan Mcnichol Pennsylvania
Craig Ruby Missouri
Arnold Oss Minnesota
Andrew Stannard Pennsylvania

1917-18 NCAA

1st Team
Harold Gillen Minnesota
Alfred Sorenson Washington State
Bill Chandler Wisconsin
Craig Ruby Missouri
Earl Anderson Illinois
Eber Simpson Wisconsin
Gene Vidal Army
George Sweeney Pennsylvania
Hubert Peck Pennsylvania
Joseph Schwarzer Syracuse

1916-17 NCAA

1st Team
George Hjelte University of California
Charles Taft Yale
Clyde Alwood Illinois
Cyril Haas Princeton
F.I. Reynolds Kansas State
Francis Stadsvold Minnesota
Harold Olsen Wisconsin
Harry Young Washington & Lee
Orson Kinney Yale
Ray Woods Illinois

1915-16 NCAA

1st Team
Clyde Littlefield Texas
Ade Sieberts Oregon State
Bill Chandler Wisconsin
Cyril Haas Princeton
Dick Romney Utah
Edward McNichol Pennsylvania
Fred Williams Missouri
George Levis Wisconsin
Ray Woods Illinois
Roy Bohler Washington State

1914-15 NCAA

1st Team
Charlie Lee Columbia
WP Arnold Yale
Wellington Stickley Virginia
Tony Savage Washington
Ray Woods Illinois
Ralph Sproull Kansas
Leslie Brown Cornell
George Levis Wisconsin
Ernest Houghton Union (NY)
Elmer Oliphant Army

1913-14 NCAA

1st Team
Walter Lunden Cornell
Nelson Norgren Chicago
Lewis Castle Syracuse
Gil Halstead Cornell
Everett Southwick City College of New York
Eugene Van Gent Wisconsin
Ernest Houghton Union (NY)
Elmer Oliphant Purdue
Dan Meenan Columbia
Carl Harper Wisconsin

1912-13 NCAA

1st Team
Laurence Wild Navy
Allen Johnson Wisconsin
Alphonse Schumacher Dayton
Eddie Calder St. Lawrence
Edward Hayward Wesleyan (CT)
Gil Halstead Cornell
Hamilton Salmon Princeton
Larry Teeple Purdue
Sam Carrier Nebraska
William Roberts Army

1911-12 NCAA

1st Team
Lewis Castle Syracuse
Alphonse Schumacher Dayton
Bebe Benson Columbia
Emil Schradieck Colgate
Ernst Mensel Dartmouth
Fred Gieg Swarthmore
Otto Stangel Wisconsin
Rufus Sisson Dartmouth
Thomas Canfield St. Lawrence
William Turner Pennsylvania

1910-11 NCAA

1st Team
Dave Charters Purdue
AD Alexander Columbia
CC Clementson Washington
Frank Lawler Minnesota
Harry Hill Navy
John Keenan St. John's (NY)
Lewis Walton Pennsylvania
Ted Kiendl Columbia
Walter Scoville Wisconsin
WM Lee Columbia

1909-10 NCAA

1st Team
Charles Eberle Swarthmore
William Copthorne Army
William Broadhead New York University
Vaughn Lewis Williams
Ted Kiendl Columbia
Samuel Harman Rochester (NY)
Pat Page Chicago
Leon Campbell Colgate
Ernest Lambert Oklahoma
Dave Charters Purdue