Consensus All-America Teams (1904-05 to 1908-09)

Total number of selections are listed in parentheses for repeat winners.

1908-09 NCAA

1st Team
Tommy Johnson Kansas
Ted Kiendl Columbia
Raymond Scanlon Notre Dame
Pat Page Chicago
Julian Hayward Wesleyan (CT)
John Schommer Chicago
John Ryan Columbia
Helmer Swenholt Wisconsin
Charles Keinath Pennsylvania
Biaggio Cerussi Columbia

1907-08 NCAA

1st Team
Julian Hayward Wesleyan (CT)
Charles Keinath Pennsylvania
Haskell Noyes Yale
Helmer Swenholt Wisconsin
Hugh Harper Wisconsin
Ira Streusand City College of New York
John Pryor Brown
John Ryan Columbia
John Schommer Chicago
Pat Page Chicago

1906-07 NCAA

1st Team
John Ryan Columbia
Parson Warren Williams
Oswald Tower Williams
Marcus Hurley Columbia
John Schommer Chicago
Gilmore Kinney Yale
George Flint Pennsylvania
Charles Keinath Pennsylvania
Arthur Frank Wisconsin
Albert Houghton Chicago

1905-06 NCAA

1st Team
George Flint Pennsylvania
Charles Keinath Pennsylvania
Eugene Cowell Williams
Garfield Brown Minnesota
George Grebenstein Dartmouth
Harold Amberg Harvard
James Mckeag Chicago
John Schommer Chicago
Marcus Hurley Columbia
Ralph Griffiths Harvard

1904-05 NCAA

1st Team
C.D. Mclees Wisconsin
Willard Hyatt Yale
Walter Runge Colgate
Oliver deGray Vanderbilt Princeton
Marcus Hurley Columbia
James Ozanne Chicago
Harry Fisher Columbia
Gilmore Kinney Yale
George Tuck Minnesota
Chris Steinmetz Wisconsin