| Year | Player | Yds | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Riley Stephenson* | 2681 | Brigham Young |
| 2011 | Ben Turk* | 2136 | Notre Dame |
| 2010 | Ben Turk* | 2607 | Notre Dame |
| 2009 | Jonathan Bulls | 2819 | Army |
| 2008 | Andrew Rinehart | 2349 | Army |
| 2007 | Owen Tolson | 3283 | Army |
| 2006 | Jake Brownell | 3004 | Temple |
| 2005 | Owen Tolson | 2370 | Army |
| 2004 | D.J. Fitzpatrick* | 3175 | Notre Dame |
| 2003 | Thomas Olmsted | 3304 | Troy |
| 2002 | Joey Hildbold* | 3038 | Notre Dame |
| 2001 | Joey Hildbold | 2703 | Notre Dame |
| 2000 | Grant Autrey | 3005 | Louisiana-Lafayette |