| Rk | Date | Day | Winner/Tie | Pts | Loser/Tie | Pts | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Oct 25, 1873 | Sat | Columbia | 2 | @ | Stevens | 1 | |
| 2 | Oct 25, 1873 | Sat | Yale | 3 | Rutgers | 1 | ||
| Rk | Date | Day | Winner/Tie | Pts | Loser/Tie | Pts | Notes | |
| 3 | Nov 1, 1873 | Sat | Rutgers | 5 | Columbia | 4 | ||
| Rk | Date | Day | Winner/Tie | Pts | Loser/Tie | Pts | Notes | |
| 4 | Nov 8, 1873 | Sat | Columbia | 4 | Rutgers | 3 | ||
| Rk | Date | Day | Winner/Tie | Pts | Loser/Tie | Pts | Notes | |
| 5 | Nov 15, 1873 | Sat | Princeton | 3 | @ | Yale | 0 |