| Rank | Player | Avg | Year | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Mark Mariscal* | 47.55 | 2002 | Colorado |
| 2. | John Torp* | 46.54 | 2004 | Colorado |
| 3. | Sam Koch* | 46.51 | 2005 | Nebraska |
| 4. | Daniel Sepulveda | 46.48 | 2006 | Baylor |
| 5. | Quinn Sharp* | 46.28 | 2011 | Oklahoma State |
| 6. | Quinn Sharp* | 46.27 | 2012 | Oklahoma State |
| 7. | Quinn Sharp* | 46.24 | 2010 | Oklahoma State |
| 8. | Daniel Sepulveda | 46.18 | 2005 | Baylor |
| 9. | Daniel Sepulveda | 45.97 | 2004 | Baylor |
| 10. | Justin Brantly | 45.71 | 2008 | Texas A&M |
| 11. | Tress Way* | 45.69 | 2009 | Oklahoma |
| 12. | Alex King* | 45.30 | 2012 | Texas |
| 13. | Alex Reyes* | 45.19 | 2006 | Texas Tech |
| 14. | Kirby Van Der Kamp | 45.17 | 2010 | Iowa State |
| 15. | John Torp* | 45.16 | 2005 | Colorado |
| 16. | Kyle Larson* | 45.12 | 2003 | Nebraska |
| 17. | Quinn Sharp* | 45.12 | 2009 | Oklahoma State |
| 18. | Matt Fodge* | 44.88 | 2006 | Oklahoma State |
| 19. | Trey Barrow* | 44.82 | 2011 | Missouri |
| 20. | Derek Epperson | 44.81 | 2009 | Baylor |
| 21. | Tim Reyer | 44.53 | 2007 | Kansas State |
| 22. | Mark Mariscal | 44.51 | 2001 | Colorado |
| 23. | Ethan Perry* | 44.51 | 2012 | Texas Christian |
| 24. | Justin Brantly* | 44.30 | 2006 | Texas A&M |
| 25. | Derek Epperson | 44.27 | 2008 | Baylor |