| Rank | Player | Y/A | Year | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Bradlee Van Pelt* | 9.58 | 2003 | Colorado State |
| 2. | John Beck* | 9.32 | 2006 | Brigham Young |
| 3. | Alex Smith* | 9.31 | 2004 | Utah |
| 4. | Ryan Lindley* | 9.10 | 2010 | San Diego State |
| 5. | Andy Dalton* | 9.04 | 2010 | Texas Christian |
| 6. | Tim Jefferson* | 8.95 | 2011 | Air Force |
| 7. | Brian Johnson* | 8.76 | 2005 | Utah |
| 8. | Max Hall* | 8.70 | 2009 | Brigham Young |
| 9. | Brandon Doman | 8.68 | 2001 | Brigham Young |
| 10. | Kellen Moore* | 8.66 | 2011 | Boise State |
| 11. | Mike Thiessen | 8.65 | 2000 | Air Force |
| 12. | Justin Holland* | 8.63 | 2005 | Colorado State |
| 13. | Brett Smith | 8.60 | 2012 | Wyoming |
| 14. | Andy Dalton* | 8.53 | 2009 | Texas Christian |
| 15. | Casey Pachall* | 8.52 | 2011 | Texas Christian |
| 16. | Jason Thomas | 8.50 | 2000 | Nevada-Las Vegas |
| 17. | Alex Smith* | 8.45 | 2003 | Utah |
| 18. | Caleb Hanie | 8.38 | 2007 | Colorado State |
| 19. | Jay Stoner | 8.37 | 1999 | Wyoming |
| 20. | Max Hall* | 8.30 | 2008 | Brigham Young |
| 21. | Justin Holland | 8.23 | 2004 | Colorado State |
| 22. | Darnell Arceneaux | 8.14 | 2000 | Utah |
| 23. | Darnell Arceneaux | 8.13 | 1999 | Utah |
| 24. | Casey Kelly* | 8.11 | 2003 | New Mexico |
| 25. | Derek Carr* | 8.03 | 2012 | Fresno State |