| Rank | Player | Cmp | Year | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Chris Vargas | 331 | 1993 | Nevada |
| 2. | Doug Gaynor | 321 | 1985 | Long Beach State |
| 3. | Todd Dillon | 289 | 1982 | Long Beach State |
| 4. | Mike Maxwell | 277 | 1995 | Nevada |
| 5. | Troy Kopp | 275 | 1991 | Pacific |
| 6. | Mike Maxwell | 271 | 1994 | Nevada |
| 7. | Mike Perez* | 269 | 1987 | San Jose State |
| 8. | Ryan Fien | 267 | 1996 | Idaho |
| 9. | Cody Ledbetter | 259 | 1995 | New Mexico State |
| 10. | John Welsh | 251 | 2000 | Idaho |
| 11. | Mike Perez* | 249 | 1986 | San Jose State |
| Steve Clarkson* | 249 | 1981 | San Jose State | |
| 13. | Doug Gaynor | 248 | 1984 | Long Beach State |
| 14. | David Neill | 247 | 1999 | Nevada |
| Anthony Calvillo | 247 | 1993 | Utah State | |
| 16. | Brent Snyder | 246 | 1988 | Utah State |
| 17. | Jeff Graham | 245 | 1986 | Long Beach State |
| 18. | Troy Kopp | 244 | 1990 | Pacific |
| 19. | Ed Luther | 241 | 1979 | San Jose State |
| 20. | Kevin Sweeney | 227 | 1984 | Fresno State |
| 21. | Jeff Graham | 226 | 1988 | Long Beach State |
| Brent Snyder | 226 | 1987 | Utah State | |
| 23. | John Dutton | 225 | 1997 | Nevada |
| Randall Cunningham* | 225 | 1984 | Nevada-Las Vegas | |
| 25. | John Dutton | 222 | 1996 | Nevada |