| Year | Player | Avg | School |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2012 | Montel Harris | 5.67 | Temple |
| 2011 | Ray Graham* | 5.84 | Pittsburgh |
| 2010 | Isaiah Pead | 6.55 | Cincinnati |
| 2009 | Isaiah Pead* | 6.66 | Cincinnati |
| 2008 | Noel Devine* | 6.26 | West Virginia |
| 2007 | Pat White* | 6.78 | West Virginia |
| 2006 | Pat White* | 7.39 | West Virginia |
| 2005 | George Stripling* | 7.86 | Louisville |
| 2004 | Kay-Jay Harris* | 5.81 | West Virginia |
| 2003 | Kevin Jones* | 5.86 | Virginia Tech |
| 2002 | Quincy Wilson* | 6.44 | West Virginia |
| 2001 | William Green | 5.88 | Boston College |
| 2000 | James Mungro | 6.93 | Syracuse |
| 1999 | Andre Kendrick* | 6.21 | Virginia Tech |
| 1998 | James Jackson | 6.65 | Miami (FL) |
| 1997 | James Jackson | 7.35 | Miami (FL) |
| 1996 | Ken Oxendine | 5.93 | Virginia Tech |
| 1995 | Mike Cloud | 6.14 | Boston College |
| 1994 | Malcolm Thomas | 5.68 | Syracuse |
| 1993 | Terrell Willis | 6.47 | Rutgers |
| 1992 | Chuckie Dukes | 5.83 | Boston College |
| 1991 | Chuckie Dukes | 6.31 | Boston College |