| Rank | Player | Avg | From | To | Last School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Pat McAfee* | 43.75 | 2005 | 2008 | West Virginia |
| 2. | Rob Long* | 43.28 | 2007 | 2010 | Syracuse |
| 3. | Brendan Carney* | 42.56 | 2003 | 2006 | Syracuse |
| 4. | Adam Graessle* | 42.55 | 2004 | 2006 | Pittsburgh |
| 5. | Andy Lee* | 42.43 | 2000 | 2003 | Pittsburgh |
| 6. | Freddie Capshaw* | 42.06 | 2000 | 2002 | Miami (FL) |
| 7. | Teddy Dellaganna* | 41.82 | 2008 | 2010 | Rutgers |
| 8. | Desi Cullen* | 41.12 | 2006 | 2009 | Connecticut |
| 9. | Mike Shafer | 40.99 | 2000 | 2002 | Syracuse |
| 10. | Cole Wagner* | 40.97 | 2010 | 2012 | Connecticut |
| 11. | Delbert Alvarado* | 40.31 | 2006 | 2009 | South Florida |
| 12. | Joe Radigan* | 40.29 | 2003 | 2006 | Rutgers |
| 13. | Mike Barr | 40.15 | 2000 | 2002 | Rutgers |
| 14. | Dave Brytus* | 40.13 | 2004 | 2008 | Pittsburgh |
| 15. | Kevin McMyler* | 40.12 | 2000 | 2002 | Boston College |
| 16. | Mark Fazzolari* | 39.84 | 1999 | 2002 | West Virginia |
| 17. | Vinnie Burns* | 39.61 | 2001 | 2004 | Virginia Tech |
| 18. | Cory Goettsche* | 39.60 | 2006 | 2009 | Louisville |
| 19. | Justin Doerner* | 38.58 | 2011 | 2012 | Rutgers |
| 20. | Justin Brockhaus-Kann* | 38.06 | 2010 | 2012 | South Florida |