| Rank | Player | XPM | Year | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Jimmy Stevens* | 94 | 2008 | Oklahoma |
| 2. | Quinn Sharp* | 79 | 2011 | Oklahoma State |
| 3. | Aaron Jones* | 75 | 2011 | Baylor |
| 4. | Trey Dicarlo* | 74 | 2003 | Oklahoma |
| 5. | Jeff Wolfert* | 73 | 2008 | Missouri |
| 6. | Quinn Sharp* | 72 | 2012 | Oklahoma State |
| 7. | Aaron Jones* | 71 | 2012 | Baylor |
| Garrett Hartley* | 71 | 2007 | Oklahoma | |
| David Pino* | 71 | 2005 | Texas | |
| 10. | Dan Bailey* | 68 | 2010 | Oklahoma State |
| 11. | Alex Trlica* | 67 | 2007 | Texas Tech |
| Jeff Wolfert* | 67 | 2007 | Missouri | |
| Joe Rheem* | 67 | 2003 | Kansas State | |
| 14. | Scott Webb* | 66 | 2007 | Kansas |
| Keith Toogood* | 66 | 2003 | Texas Tech | |
| 16. | Dan Bailey* | 65 | 2008 | Oklahoma State |
| 17. | Tyler Bitancurt* | 64 | 2012 | West Virginia |
| Anthony Cantele* | 64 | 2012 | Kansas State | |
| 19. | Hunter Lawrence* | 61 | 2009 | Texas |
| 20. | Matt Williams* | 60 | 2009 | Texas Tech |
| Hunter Lawrence* | 60 | 2008 | Texas | |
| Alex Trlica* | 60 | 2005 | Texas Tech | |
| Josh Brown | 60 | 2000 | Nebraska | |
| 24. | Ryan Bustin* | 59 | 2012 | Texas Tech |
| Tim Duncan | 59 | 2000 | Oklahoma |